{"generated_at":"2026-10-14T20:07:22+00:00","item":{"added_at":"2026-08-13","analysis_method":"independent_manual_review_2026-10-10","assessment_status":"provisional","auth_posture":"auth_required","category":"Web Connector","confidence":"medium","description":"Devil's Advocate structures critical reviews of decisions and arguments. Challenge assumptions, run premortems, and build attack-tree analyses. Combine multiple perspectives and examine possible contradictions or reasoning flaws.","did":"6e040acd-8826-40e4-a886-a13dd8c2aa91","documentation_url":"https://reasoning.services/docs/","editorial_description":{"extended_description":"Built-in perspectives include attacker, competitor, skeptic, pessimist, contrarian, and auditor. Tools add perspectives, generate targeted challenges, and synthesize findings through authenticated access.","schema_version":1,"summary":"Devil's Advocate structures critical reviews of decisions and arguments.\nChallenge assumptions, run premortems, and build attack-tree analyses.\nCombine multiple perspectives and examine possible contradictions or reasoning flaws."},"homepage_url":"","icon":"","id":"6e040acd-8826-40e4-a886-a13dd8c2aa91","installs":0,"last_scanned":"","license":"","long_description":"Built-in perspectives include attacker, competitor, skeptic, pessimist, contrarian, and auditor. Tools add perspectives, generate targeted challenges, and synthesize findings through authenticated access.","manual_assessment":"medium","manual_review":{"all_findings":[{"evidence":"The multi-step inventory starts an analysis then adds perspectives before synthesis, and publisher documentation says reasoning sessions are retained for reference.","reasoning":"These are durable account-side analysis records.","risk_type":"data_modification","severity":"medium","title":"Creates and extends stored adversarial-analysis sessions","triggering_tools_or_skills":["start_adversarial_analysis","add_perspective"]},{"evidence":"The service receives user-supplied decision arguments and returns stored analysis.","reasoning":"Strategic decisions may contain sensitive business information.","risk_type":"private_data_read","severity":"low","title":"Processes private decision and vulnerability material","triggering_tools_or_skills":["analyze_argument_structure","challenge_assumptions","run_premortem","synthesize_challenges"]}],"assessment_status":"provisional","auth_and_scopes":"A subscription account/API key is required; submitted decision material and analysis sessions are stored privately.","blocked_missing_evidence":null,"confidence":"medium","displayed_risk":"medium","evidence_completeness":"partial","manual_overall_risk":"medium","official_sources":[{"accessed_at":"2026-10-10T20:24:37Z","url_or_path":"plutosecurity/plutonium@b749c8dc43536c794409be9805edd48063f045e2:app/data/conn/claudesec/6e040acd-8826-40e4-a886-a13dd8c2aa91.json","what_it_proves":"Candidate PR #125 record identity (name \"Devil's Advocate\", publisher, type web_connector) and 8 stored tool names; no tool descriptions stored"},{"accessed_at":"2026-09-22T10:46:07Z","url_or_path":"https://api.anthropic.com/api/directory/servers?verified_tier=anthropic,partner,community (snapshot claude-directory-all-tiers-2026-09-22.json)","what_it_proves":"Official Claude Directory listing https://claude.ai/directory/6e040acd-8826-40e4-a886-a13dd8c2aa91: complete tool_names inventory (8 tools), remote streamable-http endpoint https://reasoning.services/tools/devils-advocate/mcp, auth_posture auth_required, directory tier community"},{"accessed_at":"2026-10-10T21:12:00Z","url_or_path":"https://reasoning.services/docs/","what_it_proves":"Official docs identify authenticated staged reasoning tools; the publisher states private sessions are stored for later reference."}],"primary_reason":"Devil’s Advocate creates persistent private reasoning sessions and adds analysis state to them.","provisional_risk":null,"publication_recommendation":"accept","requires_runtime_verification":true,"review_key":"claude:6e040acd-8826-40e4-a886-a13dd8c2aa91","reviewed_at":"2026-10-10","reviewer_notes":"Reviewed all eight tools. They do not act on the analyzed systems, send messages or execute code.","risk_domains":{"arbitrary_network_access":"false","authz_ambiguity":"false","browser_control":"false","credential_or_admin_actions":"false","deletes_data":"false","deployment_or_infrastructure":"false","dynamic_hidden_actions":"false","filesystem_or_repo_access":"false","forwards_data_to_third_party":"true","modifies_data":"true","persistent_credentials":"true","prompt_injection_exposure":"true","provenance_uncertainty":"true","reads_private_data":"true","runs_code_or_queries":"false","sends_messages_as_user":"false","spends_or_moves_money":"false"},"tools_or_skills_reviewed":8,"tools_or_skills_total":8},"name":"Devil's Advocate","needs_runtime_verification":true,"plutonium_url":"https://plutonium.pluto.security/detail.html?planet=claudesec&did=6e040acd-8826-40e4-a886-a13dd8c2aa91&utm_source=plutonium_analysis_skill&utm_medium=claude_skill&utm_campaign=connector_risk_assessment","privacy_policy_url":"https://reasoning.services/privacy/","provisional_risk":null,"publication_recommendation":"accept","publisher":"Reasoning.services","publisher_url":"https://reasoning.services/","remote_url":"https://reasoning.services/tools/devils-advocate/mcp","repository_url":"","risk":"medium","risk_severity":"medium","security_risks":[{"description":"This connector can create, update, configure, or otherwise change connected resources. Review findings: These are durable account-side analysis records.","evidence":"Creates and extends stored adversarial-analysis sessions: The multi-step inventory starts an analysis then adds perspectives before synthesis, and publisher documentation says reasoning sessions are retained for reference.","manual_risk_type":"data_modification","remediation":{"block_tool_categories":["state_change"],"steps":["Use a test account or sandbox before allowing changes to production data.","Grant only the write permissions required for the intended workflow.","Require human confirmation for consequential state changes."]},"risk_type":"modifies_data","severity":"medium","title":"Creates and extends stored adversarial-analysis sessions","triggering_tools":["start_adversarial_analysis","add_perspective"]},{"description":"This connector can read information available to the connected account and return it to the AI. Review findings: Strategic decisions may contain sensitive business information.","evidence":"Processes private decision and vulnerability material: The service receives user-supplied decision arguments and returns stored analysis.","manual_risk_type":"private_data_read","remediation":{"block_tool_categories":["data_exfiltration"],"steps":["Use a least-privilege account limited to the information required by the workflow.","Restrict folders, projects, tenants, and other data scopes wherever the provider allows it.","Review access logs for unexpected reads or bulk retrieval."]},"risk_type":"reads_private_data","severity":"low","title":"Processes private decision and vulnerability material","triggering_tools":["analyze_argument_structure","challenge_assumptions","run_premortem","synthesize_challenges"]}],"signature_status":"unknown","source_code_reviewed":false,"support_url":"https://reasoning.services/contact/","tags":["modifies_data","network_access","oauth_required","reads_private_data","web_connector"],"tools":[{"description":"","name":"add_perspective","risk":{"category":"state_change","level":"medium","recommendation":"Follow the connector-level remediation and require approval for consequential actions.","why":"This connector can create, update, configure, or otherwise change connected resources. Review findings: These are durable account-side analysis records."}},{"description":"","name":"analyze_argument_structure"},{"description":"","name":"attack_tree_analysis"},{"description":"","name":"challenge_assumptions"},{"description":"","name":"generate_targeted_challenges"},{"description":"","name":"run_premortem"},{"description":"","name":"start_adversarial_analysis","risk":{"category":"state_change","level":"medium","recommendation":"Follow the connector-level remediation and require approval for consequential actions.","why":"This connector can create, update, configure, or otherwise change connected resources. Review findings: These are durable account-side analysis records."}},{"description":"","name":"synthesize_challenges"}],"tools_count":8,"transport":"streamable-http","type":"web_connector","url":"https://claude.ai/directory/6e040acd-8826-40e4-a886-a13dd8c2aa91","uuid":"88fb4631-5bf9-527a-81dd-2de253da3b68","verification_tier":"community","version":""},"query_key":"devil s advocate","schema_version":1,"status":"match"}